Scilly Cay: Anguilla’s Tiny Island with a Big Reputation
In this guide
Some of Anguilla’s greatest experiences aren’t found on the main island at all. Just offshore from the picturesque fishing village of Island Harbour sits Scilly Cay, a tiny private island that has become one of the island’s most memorable dining and day-trip destinations.
Measuring only a few acres, Scilly Cay has earned an international reputation for fresh seafood, breathtaking turquoise waters, and a laid-back Caribbean atmosphere that perfectly captures the spirit of Anguilla.
Whether you’re planning your first visit to the island or returning for another Caribbean escape, Scilly Cay is a destination that deserves a place on your itinerary.
A Short Boat Ride to Paradise
One of the things that makes Scilly Cay so special is how easy it is to reach.
Visitors simply make their way to Island Harbour, where a short boat ride transports guests across the calm waters to the island in just a few minutes.
The journey itself forms part of the experience, offering beautiful views back towards Anguilla’s coastline and the colourful fishing boats that line the harbour.
It is a simple crossing that quickly transports visitors into a completely different world.
Famous for Fresh Seafood
Scilly Cay has become one of Anguilla’s best-known lunch destinations.
Its relaxed open-air restaurant has welcomed visitors for decades and is particularly famous for serving freshly prepared seafood in an unforgettable waterfront setting.
Popular dishes often include:
- Fresh lobster (seasonal)
- Grilled crayfish
- Local fish
- Chicken options
- Caribbean side dishes
- Homemade rum punch
Dining beneath the shade of palm trees while overlooking the turquoise Caribbean Sea creates an experience that many visitors describe as one of the highlights of their holiday.
Crystal Clear Caribbean Waters
The waters surrounding Scilly Cay are every bit as spectacular as the island itself.
Many visitors choose to spend time:
- Swimming
- Snorkelling
- Relaxing on the shoreline
- Photographing the scenery
The calm, crystal-clear water makes the island particularly appealing for couples, families, and anyone looking to enjoy a peaceful afternoon in the Caribbean.
A Relaxed Island Atmosphere
Unlike larger tourist attractions, Scilly Cay has retained its intimate and authentic character.
There are no large resorts, busy roads, or commercial developments.
Instead, visitors can simply enjoy:
- Caribbean hospitality
- Ocean views
- Gentle sea breezes
- Fresh island cuisine
- A slower pace of life
It’s the kind of place where time seems to slow down, encouraging visitors to truly relax and embrace the island lifestyle.
Combine Your Visit with Island Harbour
Because Scilly Cay is accessed from Island Harbour, many visitors choose to spend the day exploring both destinations.
After enjoying lunch on Scilly Cay, visitors can return to Island Harbour to experience:
- The working fishing harbour
- Waterfront restaurants
- Scenic coastal walks
- Local shops
- Traditional island culture
Together, the two destinations provide one of the most authentic experiences available anywhere in Anguilla.
Getting There
Island Harbour is located on the north eastern coast of Anguilla and can be reached in approximately 25 minutes by car from Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport.
Having your own rental vehicle makes it easy to explore the surrounding area before or after your visit to Scilly Cay.
Vehicles can be collected from:
- Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport
- Blowing Point Ferry Terminal
Villa, hotel, and holiday rental delivery is also available throughout Anguilla.
Final Thoughts
Scilly Cay may be one of the smallest destinations in Anguilla, but it leaves one of the biggest impressions.
Its combination of fresh seafood, stunning Caribbean waters, friendly hospitality, and spectacular scenery has made it a favourite among both locals and visitors for generations.
If you’re looking to discover one of Anguilla’s most unique experiences, few places capture the island’s charm quite like Scilly Cay.
